Which barrel cooler is the best?

FURMAN

LRO Rifle and Gear Review Editor
Staff member
Joined
May 27, 2015
Messages
2,664
Reaction score
2,223
Points
113
Location
Emporia Ks
Over the next few months I will be comparing a few of the barrel coolers on the market. This one should be a pretty simple test but feel free to ask any questions. In this comparison the heat transfer rate will be directly related to the mass air flow rate since the cooling medium(ambient air) and the barrel will be the same. We do not need to actually check temperature changes because of this. The cooler that moves the most air down the barrel will be the cooler that removes the most heat. I will try to check some temperature changes just to get a feel for how effective the best one actually is. I plan on testing...
Riflekuhl Barrel Cooler – MagnetoSpeed
BarrelCool | Shooting accessories for accuracy, reloading, and hunting.
Chamber Chiller - BETA-60 AA Chamber Chiller Version 3 2019
The Original Gun Barrel Cooler | Area 1 Sports

EDIT 6/24/20 to add review link. Rifle Barrel Cooler Performance Flow Test and Comparison

 

Yoteklr

Active member
Joined
Apr 27, 2017
Messages
299
Reaction score
114
Points
43
Location
Indiana
I use a Coleman rechargeable mattress pump and flex tubing...$25. The pump lasts for about three years. One charge is good for about 40 shots.
Screenshot_20200623-200232_Photos.jpg
 

Brendan

Active member
Joined
Apr 2, 2015
Messages
207
Reaction score
139
Points
43
I have one of the "Original Barrel Coolers" - I guess I got lucky picking that one. One thing I've noticed though is the battery compartment is a little finicky. I have a hard time fitting some of the rechargeable AA's I have in there, and sometimes they don't seat 100%.

Also, the hose I have came with a little orange "Chamber Flag" for use at the range. That's required where I shoot if it makes a difference to you.
 

RBanta66

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 3, 2020
Messages
481
Reaction score
457
Points
63
Location
Virginia,
Great comparison of available products. Definitely got my wheels turning as I've never used any kind of barrel cooler or cooling method other than time between shots. That being said I already have everything needed. Might give it a try next range session definitely hot enough around here.
 

Brendan

Active member
Joined
Apr 2, 2015
Messages
207
Reaction score
139
Points
43
Problem with that is then you need to buy D cells, and potentially a charger which evens out the cost. I don't have anything that uses them anymore, don't have any in the house, and sure as heck don't want to buy a charger and a bunch of rechargeable ones.

I'm already good to go with AA's in that regard, so don't even have to buy batteries to keep it running and have multiple sets of spares.

It definitely moves more air, but not practical for me.
 

Ladd

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Messages
4,490
Reaction score
4,453
Points
113
Location
St. George UT
I wanted to add some additional numbers that I think are important. I'm not going to get into the calculations for the heat transfer rate through the barrel radius. That requires differential calculus and I would say as Ryan did in his very well put video that there are too many variables.

Air flow rate which is the volumetric flow rate of the air is one of the more important numbers and is referred to as cfm in the HVAC industry. I took the velocity numbers Ryan measured in the video with the 5 different options and took them a bit further. The more interesting number to me is the air change rate. This is the number of times the air in the barrel, in this case, will be removed and replaced in a certain amount of time. I listed air changes per minute because that's the time period we're usually waiting...minutes. I didn't calculate the cooling time for reasons stated above but that's what everyone wants to know, right?. Well, I think that would be everyone's homework and is better researched experimentally anyway.

The clear winner here is the Coleman Quickpump with over 14 air changes per minute and 4x more air changes than the Riflekuhl. When dealing with warm ambient air, the more the better.
18f9bd37482726cf7e69c1dba6bf1c80.jpg
 

Ladd

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Messages
4,490
Reaction score
4,453
Points
113
Location
St. George UT
I still like the Riflekuhl even though it may take double or more time. The magnet helps keep it in place when I stand the rifle up in the shade of the nearby tree or against the tire of my truck while I make notes in my logbook or check out the target. Double the airflow would be nice though, 4x even better. I'll look into getting a 2nd device.
 

Broz

LRO Owner~Editor~Long Range Hunting Specilist
Joined
Apr 17, 2013
Messages
11,953
Reaction score
5,241
Points
113
Location
Foot of the Big Belt Mountains near Townsend MT.
Size, weight, and battery size and life mean something to me for my needs. If shooting a match, I dont want to have to pull a wagon for my barrel cooler. Jokes aside, I like the Magneto speed barrel cooler we know it works and fits in a shirt pocket, and I am still on the first set of Batteries. Not the fastest, but made a big difference when used between stages and while waiting for our squad to shoot.
 

Papa Charlie

Active member
Joined
Sep 24, 2016
Messages
390
Reaction score
128
Points
43
Location
Everett, WA
Over the next few months I will be comparing a few of the barrel coolers on the market. This one should be a pretty simple test but feel free to ask any questions. In this comparison the heat transfer rate will be directly related to the mass air flow rate since the cooling medium(ambient air) and the barrel will be the same. We do not need to actually check temperature changes because of this. The cooler that moves the most air down the barrel will be the cooler that removes the most heat. I will try to check some temperature changes just to get a feel for how effective the best one actually is. I plan on testing...
Riflekuhl Barrel Cooler – MagnetoSpeed
BarrelCool | Shooting accessories for accuracy, reloading, and hunting.
Chamber Chiller - BETA-60 AA Chamber Chiller Version 3 2019
The Original Gun Barrel Cooler | Area 1 Sports

EDIT 6/24/20 to add review link. Rifle Barrel Cooler Performance Flow Test and Comparison

Ryan,
Nicely done report. I am glad to see that you kept the information to the facts and appreciate the information.

I like the more aggressive air flow but not the size and at my range the need for a flag is essential. The MS, even though lower in air volume moved, seems like a great option with the magnet. I have trouble keeping the flag in my rifle sometimes.

I wanted to add some additional numbers that I think are important. I'm not going to get into the calculations for the heat transfer rate through the barrel radius. That requires differential calculus and I would say as Ryan did in his very well put video that there are too many variables.

Air flow rate which is the volumetric flow rate of the air is one of the more important numbers and is referred to as cfm in the HVAC industry. I took the velocity numbers Ryan measured in the video with the 5 different options and took them a bit further. The more interesting number to me is the air change rate. This is the number of times the air in the barrel, in this case, will be removed and replaced in a certain amount of time. I listed air changes per minute because that's the time period we're usually waiting...minutes. I didn't calculate the cooling time for reasons stated above but that's what everyone wants to know, right?. Well, I think that would be everyone's homework and is better researched experimentally anyway.

The clear winner here is the Coleman Quickpump with over 14 air changes per minute and 4x more air changes than the Riflekuhl. When dealing with warm ambient air, the more the better.
18f9bd37482726cf7e69c1dba6bf1c80.jpg

Thank you for putting this together. I like data.
 

J2shooter

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 10, 2020
Messages
786
Reaction score
683
Points
93
Planning on heading to the range in the morning and I'll try to get a little cool time data while I'm at it. Maybe it'll be somewhat useful information even though it'll be specific to one rifle/barrel/caliber and and there's an infinite number of variables.

Plan is to keep it really simple.
*5 round string.
*Start the timer once the barrel Temp levels out on the stick on thermometer.
*Stop the timer once the barrel temp comes back down to +/- 5° outside temp
*5 more, start timer and barrel cool when temp tops out.
*Stop timer when it gets down to +/- 5 outside temp

I helped the stick on thermometer with a wrap of clear packing tape...I doubt it would stay by itself and others have mentioned trouble with that as well.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20200630-122746.png
    Screenshot_20200630-122746.png
    914.1 KB · Views: 45

J2shooter

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 10, 2020
Messages
786
Reaction score
683
Points
93
So the barrel cool device knocked approximately 5 minutes off the cool time.

I started and stopped the stop watch as close as my eyes could tell that the temp strip was at about he same point for both five round strings.

Took 23 minutes to cool down without barrel cool and 18 to cool down on the next round with the barrel cool in.

It'll work fine for my needs. I have to run an empty chamber flag anyway so I'm satisfied with it.

Edit:
270 Win
58.1 4831SC
129 LRX
Avg velocity 2960
 

Attachments

  • image000000.jpg
    image000000.jpg
    353 KB · Views: 39
  • image000001.jpg
    image000001.jpg
    354.4 KB · Views: 35
Last edited:

Blobby159

Active member
Joined
Nov 16, 2018
Messages
152
Reaction score
68
Points
28
Well done "J2shooter"... Nicely managed, but which barrel cooler are you actually testing there please?
I have a 'Coleman Rechargeable Quickpump' and it fairly whacks the air out and down my hot rifle barrel so it does cool that off quite quickly...

It is a moderately heavy, external lump with a built-in, rechargeable lead acid battery and it was initially designed for quickly blowing up inflatables like temporary overnight mattresses & beach lilos etc so it certainly has the oomph!! It is a trifle noisy too, but it does the barrel cooling job with aplomb - which is why I bought it in the first place so I am happy as Larry!.....

It helps immensely when I am on the range with trial loads - which is often - and I need ALL my time to shoot lotsa rounds and register the results, NOT sit about for literally hours waiting for my Tikka's heavy barrel to cool down again for the next string of shots.

The barrel of my home loaded 6.5 Swede heats up initially with perhaps a string of just 10 to 15 shots. Then, like many here reading this I am sure, I have noted that WITHOUT any forced air down it, it takes maybe 20->30 mins to cool down to just warm to the touch. It then needs but the next 5->8 or so rounds to get it sizzling hot..... AGAIN!! Then it is a repeating process of firing a short string of 5->8 shots followed by a much longer spell of (unproductive) time out to let the barrel cool back down again.... etc. etc. etc.!! A Highly Frustratingly and thoroughly ANNOYING WASTE of One's Valuable Range-time!!! This barrel cooler has been a Godsend to my load experimentation and stops me getting all hot 'n bothered and loosing off inaccurate snap shots whilst I am trying to get a full test completed, when really I should be taking my TIME and ONLY letting shots go when I am completely happy that I have the required perfect sight picture, NOT rushing cos I have wasted soooo much time waiting for my darned barrel to cool down ..... repeatedly!!!!!

If you are doing a comparator test of various coolers 'J2shooter' include an example of the one I have bought and use and I recon it will trounce all the clever little, purposely designed barrel cooler examples, by a fair margin too!..

Good luck and ATVB to you in this endeavour,
Blobbs....
 

J2shooter

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 10, 2020
Messages
786
Reaction score
683
Points
93
Well done "J2shooter"... Nicely managed, but which barrel cooler are you actually testing there please?
I have a 'Coleman Rechargeable Quickpump' and it fairly whacks the air out and down my hot rifle barrel so it does cool that off quite quickly...

It is a moderately heavy, external lump with a built-in, rechargeable lead acid battery and it was initially designed for quickly blowing up inflatables like temporary overnight mattresses & beach lilos etc so it certainly has the oomph!! It is a trifle noisy too, but it does the barrel cooling job with aplomb - which is why I bought it in the first place so I am happy as Larry!.....

.

It helps immensely when I am on the range with trial loads - which is often - and I need ALL my time to shoot lotsa rounds and register the results, NOT sit about for literally hours waiting for my Tikka's heavy barrel to cool down again for the next string of shots.

The barrel of my home loaded 6.5 Swede heats up initially with perhaps a string of just 10 to 15 shots. Then, like many here reading this I am sure, I have noted that WITHOUT any forced air down it, it takes maybe 20->30 mins to cool down to just warm to the touch. It then needs but the next 5->8 or so rounds to get it sizzling hot..... AGAIN!! Then it is a repeating process of firing a short string of 5->8 shots followed by a much longer spell of (unproductive) time out to let the barrel cool back down again.... etc. etc. etc.!! A Highly Frustratingly and thoroughly ANNOYING WASTE of One's Valuable Range-time!!! This barrel cooler has been a Godsend to my load experimentation and stops me getting all hot 'n bothered and loosing off inaccurate snap shots whilst I am trying to get a full test completed, when really I should be taking my TIME and ONLY letting shots go when I am completely happy that I have the required perfect sight picture, NOT rushing cos I have wasted soooo much time waiting for my darned barrel to cool down ..... repeatedly!!!!!

If you are doing a comparator test of various coolers 'J2shooter' include an example of the one I have bought and use and I recon it will trounce all the clever little, purposely designed barrel cooler examples, by a fair margin too!..

Good luck and ATVB to you in this endeavour,
Blobbs....

Rfurman24 did a thorough comparison of several, including the Coleman mattress pump. It did outperform all the others in the quantity of air moved category .

Run up to the top of the thread here and check out his video.

The one I'm using is in rfurman24s review. It is called the barrel cool. Pretty sure it moves the least amount of air of all the ones he tested
 

Blobby159

Active member
Joined
Nov 16, 2018
Messages
152
Reaction score
68
Points
28
Rfurman24 did a thorough comparison of several, including the Coleman mattress pump. It did outperform all the others in the quantity of air moved category .

Run up to the top of the thread here and check out his video.

The one I'm using is in rfurman24s review. It is called the barrel cool. Pretty sure it moves the least amount of air of all the ones he tested

Ha! That will teach me to check out the previous posts right to the top and not just skim read a few of the immediate ones!!.. Thank you 'J2shooter'... You are right too, the testing 'rfurman24' did IS quite comprehensive for the models in his trial that included 'my' Coleman mattress pump.... Like I mentioned in my short(?) critique it is a noisy, heavy critter but does the barrel cooling task with aplomb...
ATVB,
Blobby...


ATB ..... and shoot safely

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 

Marine 0302

New member
Joined
Feb 20, 2020
Messages
3
Reaction score
1
Points
3
J2Shooter, do you have a link to where you got the stick on thermometers ? And maybe this is an area for more testing, this time the best way to monitor barrel temperatures, the stick on's or the IR readers
 

J2shooter

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 10, 2020
Messages
786
Reaction score
683
Points
93
J2Shooter, do you have a link to where you got the stick on thermometers ? And maybe this is an area for more testing, this time the best way to monitor barrel temperatures, the stick on's or the IR readers
I got them here.

.

They get thumbs up for simplicity.
A close approximate temperature but it's a bit of guesswork too.
The IR would be more accurate I'm sure.

I'm just going to leave it on the rifle until it starts to fall off I suppose.
 

Spreedizzle

Well-known member
Joined
May 5, 2019
Messages
637
Reaction score
665
Points
93
Location
Cleveland Ohio
Reviving an older thread as I came across Ryan’s YouTube review.
For the range guys, non competition….is the Magnetospeed still at the top of the category? Or had the Barrel Chiller Pro, or others, risen to the occasion with their new features?
 

FURMAN

LRO Rifle and Gear Review Editor
Staff member
Joined
May 27, 2015
Messages
2,664
Reaction score
2,223
Points
113
Location
Emporia Ks
Reviving an older thread as I came across Ryan’s YouTube review.
For the range guys, non competition….is the Magnetospeed still at the top of the category? Or had the Barrel Chiller Pro, or others, risen to the occasion with their new features?
I’m not sure what you’re asking? The magneto speed was at the bottom of performance.
 

Spreedizzle

Well-known member
Joined
May 5, 2019
Messages
637
Reaction score
665
Points
93
Location
Cleveland Ohio
I’m not sure what you’re asking? The magneto speed was at the bottom of performance.
Seemed as though Jeff and others preferred it for the magnet, battery life and compactness….albeit with the lower amounts of air volume.
The Chamber Chiller is attractive to me just based on the usb connection, as I can use the same battery bank that I use for the Labradar.
 

FURMAN

LRO Rifle and Gear Review Editor
Staff member
Joined
May 27, 2015
Messages
2,664
Reaction score
2,223
Points
113
Location
Emporia Ks
Seemed as though Jeff and others preferred it for the magnet, battery life and compactness….albeit with the lower amounts of air volume.
The Chamber Chiller is attractive to me just based on the usb connection, as I can use the same battery bank that I use for the Labradar.
They are all just as portable. I don’t see the point of even bringing it if it’s not going to serve it’s only function which is cooling a barrel the barrel cool and the riflekuhl hardly move any air so they’re not gonna do anything relatively speaking for cooling a barrel. If you’re absolutely against taking the original barrel cooler and the hose your next best option is the chamber chiller
 

Ladd

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Messages
4,490
Reaction score
4,453
Points
113
Location
St. George UT
I carry both the Rifkekuhl and the Barrel Cooler in my range bag and have been using the Barrel Cooler exclusively. It cools the barrel quick. I prefer it now. Has anyone used the Barrel Blizzard?
 

FURMAN

LRO Rifle and Gear Review Editor
Staff member
Joined
May 27, 2015
Messages
2,664
Reaction score
2,223
Points
113
Location
Emporia Ks
I carry both the Rifkekuhl and the Barrel Cooler in my range bag and have been using the Barrel Cooler exclusively. It cools the barrel quick. I prefer it now. Has anyone used the Barrel Blizzard?
No but the design doesn’t make any sense at all we’re trying to cool the throat.
 

Diverjeff

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 20, 2019
Messages
459
Reaction score
310
Points
63
Location
Corona,CA
I’m not sure what you’re asking? The magneto speed was at the bottom of performance.
I blew $50 on one of those(MS)gizmos,wouldn't even blow a fly off of my computer screen.:ROFLMAO:
 

Ladd

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Messages
4,490
Reaction score
4,453
Points
113
Location
St. George UT
No but the design doesn’t make any sense at all we’re trying to cool the throat.
Me too. I thought it looked like a good idea until I watched the video and it only blew air on the surface outside. If they could duct those two computer fans into the chamber, that would be something.
 

OSOK - Crash

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 18, 2018
Messages
1,196
Reaction score
625
Points
113
Location
Central Indiana
They are all just as portable. I don’t see the point of even bringing it if it’s not going to serve it’s only function which is cooling a barrel the barrel cool and the riflekuhl hardly move any air so they’re not gonna do anything relatively speaking for cooling a barrel. If you’re absolutely against taking the original barrel cooler and the hose your next best option is the chamber chiller
Ryan, how do you know when the throat is cooled enough? Do you just run it for a certain time, or is there a more specific method?
 

Blobby159

Active member
Joined
Nov 16, 2018
Messages
152
Reaction score
68
Points
28
All you guys wanting a (range) cooler that WORKS!!... Review post# 17 above. The air mattress pump that I use works AH..MAZE..BALZ, I kid you not!... Like has been already mentioned here in the re-birth of this post, why buy an air mover to cool down your PRECIOUS Barrel (chamber end in particular) if it does NOT function as an Air MOOVER?.

Try it, they don't cost the Earth - MANY TIMES LESS than a New Barrel - and they Do work!

ATB ..... and shoot safely
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
Joined
Aug 6, 2021
Messages
54
Reaction score
33
Points
18
Location
Arizona
Ryan, how do you know when the throat is cooled enough? Do you just run it for a certain time, or is there a more specific method?

I have one of these thermal strips on each of my barrels just at the receiver to tell me when to cool down the barrel and when the barrel is cooled down:

Thermal Strip1.jpg

Like in this post in this thread (only it wasn't necessary to use any tape to tape it down):

 

FURMAN

LRO Rifle and Gear Review Editor
Staff member
Joined
May 27, 2015
Messages
2,664
Reaction score
2,223
Points
113
Location
Emporia Ks
Ryan, how do you know when the throat is cooled enough? Do you just run it for a certain time, or is there a more specific method?
I do not get scientific about it. I am only cooling to try to protect the throat for longevity reasons. I don't agree with cooling the barrel on carbons or larger profile barrels for accuracy purposes. Lighter profile barrels need to cool because the heat can and usually does effect accuracy.
 

OSOK - Crash

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 18, 2018
Messages
1,196
Reaction score
625
Points
113
Location
Central Indiana
I do not get scientific about it. I am only cooling to try to protect the throat for longevity reasons. I don't agree with cooling the barrel on carbons or larger profile barrels for accuracy purposes. Lighter profile barrels need to cool because the heat can and usually does effect accuracy.
Is this mainly for large calibers? Or would the throat on my creedmoor benefit from this?
 

FURMAN

LRO Rifle and Gear Review Editor
Staff member
Joined
May 27, 2015
Messages
2,664
Reaction score
2,223
Points
113
Location
Emporia Ks
Is this mainly for large calibers? Or would the throat on my creedmoor benefit from this?
Throats wear due to heat. Keeping the throat cool can only help. It will be harder to see an appreciable difference with a cartridge that is expected to shoot over 5000 rounds than one with a life expectancy of 1000 rounds.

 

Forum Sponsors

Top